Button Straddle Rule Debate: Action Starts from SB or UTG?
In WSOP cash games, the button straddle rule where action starts from the small blind has sparked player discussion. Supporters argue starting from UTG is fairer, reducing additional penalties on the blind positions; opponents believe starting from SB increases game dynamics. This article outlines the arguments for both sides.
![Button straddle rule debate: action starts from SB or UTG?]
Background
On WSOP cash tables, players are allowed to make a button straddle (the player on the button posts double the big blind preflop and gets last action preflop). However, the action order after a button straddle varies between poker rooms. On specific WSOP tables, the rule states that action starts from the small blind (SB); in many other poker rooms (including the casino where the poster regularly plays), action starts from UTG (under the gun).
Arguments for Starting from the SB
- Punishing the Blinds: Players who support starting from the SB believe it further weakens the positional advantage of the blinds and increases the aggression of the game. The button straddle itself already gives the button last action; starting from the SB puts more pressure on the blinds, forcing them to fold more often.
- Simplified Flow: Some players point out that starting from the SB avoids complex decisions for UTG after a straddle, making the game faster.
Arguments for Starting from UTG
- Fairness: Opponents of starting from the SB argue that the blinds are already at a positional disadvantage (especially the small blind), and making them act first is "adding insult to injury." Starting from UTG follows the conventional preflop action order (UTG acts first), which is more intuitive.
- Avoiding Distorted Strategy: Starting from the SB can change the standard preflop ranges and may lead to imbalanced raising strategies. For example, the SB might be forced to defend with a wider range after a straddle, while UTG gets a "free" opportunity to observe.
Discussion & Summary
Currently, both rules have their supporters, and there is no unified standard. Players generally agree that consistency in the rule is more important than the specific choice. If you are playing in a particular poker room, it's best to confirm the local rules in advance to avoid confusion.
Note: The button straddle usually appears in private games or specific cash tables; WSOP official rules may vary by event. The above content is based on player community discussion and does not represent any official position.
FAQ
- Some players believe this further penalizes the blind positions, increases game aggression, and simplifies decision-making.